Do St. Augustine restaurants take reservations?

Some do and many do not. The higher-end dining rooms downtown and in Ponte Vedra Beach take reservations, often through an online booking app. A lot of the casual favorites run a walk-up or text wait list only. If a place is important to you, call that afternoon and ask. Holiday weekends and Nights of Lights evenings book out days ahead.

What is a reasonable price for dinner in St. Johns County?

In 2026, a casual sit-down dinner runs about 20 to 35 dollars per person before drinks and tip. Mid-range spots in Ponte Vedra Beach or on the bayfront land closer to 40 to 70. Fine dining with wine can pass 100 per person. Lunch is noticeably cheaper nearly everywhere, and the same kitchen often serves smaller portions of the same dishes at midday.

Where do locals eat in St. Augustine?

Locals tend to skip St. George Street at peak times and head to Anastasia Island, Vilano Beach, the US 1 corridor and the neighborhoods along SR 16 and SR 207. In the north county, Nocatee Town Center and the Julington Creek plazas along Race Track Road are the default. Ask a server where they eat on a night off and you will get a good answer.

Is parking hard near downtown restaurants?

Yes on weekends and during events. The Historic Downtown Parking Facility by the Visitor Center is the easiest bet and charges a flat daily rate. Street spots are metered and short. Some restaurants on the edges of downtown have small lots. If you are coming from the beach, the Bridge of Lions backs up around sunset, so allow extra time.

Which months are busiest for restaurants here?

March and April bring spring break and good weather, and the holiday light season from late November through January packs downtown every night. Summer weekends are busy at the beaches. Late August through early October is the slow stretch, when it is easiest to walk in anywhere and when many restaurants run specials.

Do restaurants here add gratuity automatically?

Many do for parties of six or more, typically 18 to 20 percent, and a few downtown spots add a service charge for everyone. Florida law requires it to be disclosed on the menu or receipt. Read the bottom of the check before you add a tip, because doubling up is an easy mistake on a busy night.

904biz

For businessesAdd your business

Restaurants in Fleming Island, FL | 904biz

Home / Restaurants / Fleming Island

Restaurants in Fleming Island, FL

Restaurants nearby

St. Augustine St. Augustine Beach Ponte Vedra Beach Ponte Vedra Nocatee St. Johns Julington Creek Fruit Cove

Sponsor spot open: own the #1 position on “Restaurants in Fleming Island”. One business only.Ask about it →

Open now 904 Verified Top Rated 4+ stars 24-hour / emergency

Free, no obligation

Get matched with up to 3 verified restaurants

Tell us what you need. We send it only to 904 Verified businesses near you, and they call you. No spam, no bidding wars.

Restaurants in Fleming Island

Restaurants in Fleming Island range from quick family spots to full dinner service, and the choice usually comes down to parking, wait time and whether kids are welcome. Most Fleming Island restaurants post menus online, and the better ones answer the phone about wait lists and large parties. Weekends from 5:30 to 7:30 p.m. are the crunch. Check hours before you go, because many kitchens here close by 9 p.m. on weeknights.

How to choose a restaurant in Fleming Island

Decide on the neighborhood first
Downtown St. Augustine means paid parking and a walk, Nocatee and Julington Creek mean free lots and quicker service. Pick the area that fits the night, then pick the restaurant.
Check the posted inspection
Florida restaurants are inspected by the Department of Business and Professional Regulation, and the results are public online. A recent clean report matters more than a decade-old review.
Look at the current menu, not the photos
Prices in this county moved a lot in the last few years. Read the menu the restaurant posts now, and note whether gratuity is added for groups, which is common downtown.
Ask about wait times honestly
Many popular St. Augustine spots use a text wait list instead of reservations. Call ahead on a Friday or Saturday and ask what the wait looks like at the time you plan to arrive.
Match the place to the group
A waterfront bar on A1A is great for two adults and rough with a toddler at 7 p.m. If you have kids or a large party, pick somewhere with a real lot and quick kitchen.

What a meal costs in St. Johns County →

Related in Fleming Island

Seafood Restaurants Pizza Places Mexican Restaurants

Restaurants in Fleming Island, FL

Get matched with up to 3 verified restaurants

Restaurants in Fleming Island

How to choose a restaurant in Fleming Island

Related in Fleming Island

Restaurant questions, answered by local experts