PizzaFleming Island 4.4 (152)
Own this business and don't want to be listed? Remove my business. Something wrong here? Report a problem.
Premium listings show a 60-second video here. See Premium
Pizza in Fleming Island, FL
Is this your business?
Claim it free to fix your info, add photos and a video, answer questions, and post deals.
Claim this listing4.4 on Google from 152 reviews · Read on Google
Recent Google reviews
The gentleman who answered the phone was A+ as far as customer service goes but I was horribly disappointed in the pizza for the price. Paid $48 for one 12” and one “large one topping” not sure how it was $48 when the special was $9.99 for carry out large. That would have made the 12” pizza at least $20 which is insane. The dough was wonderful thankfully bc the pizza hardly had cheese on it at all. Really disappointed definitely will choose mellow mushroom next time.
Absolutely DELICIOUS! The dough and toppings taste fresh, the store is clean and tidy, and the employees are friendly and skilled. Shoutout to Connor! We even met the new owners who are so kind and very involved! Try the Italian steak pizza and No Brainer. You will not be disappointed.
We have eaten here a few times and food has always been good. Yesterday there was some confusion on DoorDash pick up and delivery on my end. After speaking to the workers about it their Manager got involved and was top notch hospitality. He was able to get the ordered canceled and even offered to use the honor man system that when money was back in my account that I could come and pay for it. There is not many places that would even consider the honor system much less offer it. As I stated we eat here and love it but the customer service will always bring me back.
5 stars Stoner’s Pizza in Fleming Island completely exceeded our expectations and is now the ONLY pizza our family can eat without stomach issues. Their dough and ingredients are so much gentler—no bloating or discomfort like everywhere else. The pizza was outstanding: perfect crispy-chewy crust, balanced sauce, and amazing cheese pull. Tasted fresh and gourmet yet super comforting. The owner greeted us warmly and explained why theirs stands out—fresh daily dough, quality ingredients, and a recipe that’s easier on the stomach. All veggies are cut fresh every morning, and no frozen dough! That personal touch made it special. If you’re in Fleming Island and want delicious pizza that actually agrees with you, this is it. We’ll be regulars! 🍕
Wow! My family has just found our new favorite pizza place! Since moving to the area, we have tried several local pizza places, and this one hit the ball out of the park! I am SUPER picky about pizza. Crust, dough, sauce to cheese and toppings ratio, the cook. FANTASTIC! Customers for life!
Reviews from Google. See all on Google Maps.
No 904biz reviews yet. Be the first.
No questions yet.