Siena’s Pizza

Are you looking for a new kind of pizza experience? I highly recommend Siena’s Pizza. Here you’ll find a house full of European flavors right from the kitchen oven and brought straight to the dining room table. The ingredients are always fresh and the sauce really makes the pie! The dining area is riddled with pleasant decor, antiques included, and the place is very clean. The staff is always smiling and are great to order from. No matter how you slice it (pun intended) you’ll want to order your next pie from Siena’s. A huge thanks to the team!

Sienas Pizza Address: 150 Fountains Way, suite 13 St Johns , 32259. Siena’s Pizza & Bar is the kind of casual, family-run pizzeria that makes you feel at home from the moment you walk in. They serve Chicago-style and other signature pies, along with wings, salads, and plenty of comforting favorites for both dine-in and takeout. It’s the kind of place where the food speaks for itself—fresh, generous, and made with real care. Their pizzas come out hot and beautifully crafted, with dough that’s clearly made fresh daily. You can taste the difference in every bite—the crust has that perfect balance of chew and crispness, the sauce is rich and well-seasoned, and the toppings are layered with intention. It genuinely feels like someone’s Italian nonna is in the back, guiding each pie with love and making sure nothing leaves the kitchen unless it’s just right. Their salads are just as impressive. Fresh, crisp, and customizable, you can pick your protein and build something that feels hearty and satisfying without losing that light, refreshing touch. Portions are generous, flavors are clean, and everything comes together with the kind of consistency you expect from a true neighborhood gem. The ambiance is warm, homely, and relaxed—perfect for families, casual dates, or grabbing a quick slice on the go. The staff is friendly, the service is quick, and the whole place has that welcoming charm you only find in genuinely family-owned spots. Whether you’re craving a Chicago-style pie, a fresh salad, or a laid-back place to unwind with good food, Siena’s Pizza & Bar delivers every time. It’s comforting, flavorful, and the kind of pizzeria you’ll find yourself returning to again and again.

A true taste of Italy in St. Johns! Siena’s Pizza & Bar is one of those places you walk into once — and instantly know you’ll be back. The moment you step inside, you’re welcomed with the aroma of fresh dough, bubbling cheese, and all the comforting Italian flavors you could hope for. Their thin, crispy crust has the perfect balance of crunch and chew, the sauce is rich and full of authentic Italian depth, and every topping tastes incredibly fresh and thoughtfully chosen. Beyond the pizza, everything we tried was excellent. The salads are crisp and refreshing, the wings come out hot and well-seasoned, and the mozzarella sticks are perfectly golden with that irresistible melty center. It’s comfort food prepared with real care. The service is truly what makes this place shine. Viktoriia was absolutely amazing — warm, attentive, and so knowledgeable about the menu. She made us feel right at home from the moment we sat down. And we loved that the owner, Yuliia, took the time to stop by our table to check in and chat about the unique options on their menu. That personal touch is something you can’t fake, and it shows how much love they pour into this family-run restaurant. With a kids’ zone for families and a full bar for adults, Siena’s Pizza is the perfect spot for everyone — whether you’re dining in, grabbing takeout, or ordering through DoorDash. If you want authentic Italian flavor without leaving St. Johns, this place is a must-visit. Absolutely worth every bite!

A coworker raved about this place. I took his advice and went. I'm a Connecticut pizza snob, if you know you know, and when I tell you this place delivered! Wow! Everything so fresh. You can tell the dough is homemade, totatoes from Italy and the cheese from England. We got the house special (do not pass on this one) and a Hawaiian. The atmosphere was inviting and cozy. They had an area for kids to play while parents eat. It's a lovely place and will be back.