Pizzalley's on St. George

OMG! Do yourself a favor and try this place. Amazing staff, food, and a quiet atmosphere. We will most certainly be back (most likely tomorrow). The food was stellar. We started with Happy Hour drinks and an order of Venetian Bruschetta. Main course was Blackened Chicken Fettucine Alfredo, Chicken Piccata, and 2 of us split the 16" Three Little Pigs with added onions. Portion sizes were huge. Should have done a 10" pizza to split between the two of us. I can't stress enough how amazing this place was. I would drive here (4+ hours) just for the pizza it was that impressive.

They were giving away samples of their cheese pizza on the main street in old St. Augustine and let me tell you, it was out of this world good. My son, his girlfriend, and I were blown away as to how good it was. We kept walking around site seeing and decided to find the restaurant and eat our dinner there. We ordered cokes, side salads and a large cheese pizza. The salad was fresh and the dressings (honey mustard for me and ranch for my son and his girlfriend) were homemade and delicious. The pizza was so good, not quite as good as the sample but still absolutely delicious. It also was affordable. Under $35 which to me was a great price for everything we got. Next time I'm in St. Augustine, I will definitely be back.

Literally the best pizza I've ever had. Crust was crispy and crunchy, but not burnt. Cheese pull...amazing! CRAZY GOOD flavor. I'm not normally a crust person, but I ate EVERY BITE and loved it.