904biz Top 10

2026's Best Insurance Agents in Northeast Florida

Ranked by Google rating weighted by review count, so a 4.8 with 300 reviews beats a 5.0 with 12. Minimum 10 reviews. No one can pay to be on this list.

1
Shannon Olson - State Farm Insurance Agent
Insurance Agent · St. Augustine
5.0 (683)
2
Craig Dewhurst - State Farm Insurance Agent
Insurance Agent · St. Augustine
5.0 (601)
3
Jonathan Gibbs - State Farm Insurance Agent
Insurance Agent · Nocatee
5.0 (585)
4
Brandi Mark - State Farm Insurance Agent
Insurance Agent · Fruit Cove
5.0 (435)
5
River City Claims
Insurance Agent · St. Augustine
5.0 (260)
6
Anderson Agency Insurance
Insurance Agent · Ponte Vedra Beach
5.0 (228)
7
Richard OConnor: Allstate Insurance
Insurance Agent · Fruit Cove
5.0 (173)
8
St. Johns Title
Insurance Agent · St. Augustine
5.0 (144)
9
Moran Insurance
Insurance Agent · Ponte Vedra Beach
5.0 (137)
10
Packo Financial Group
Insurance Agent · St. Augustine
5.0 (109)

Are you on this list?

Claim your listing and we'll send you a “Top 10” badge for your website and social. Claim free.

See all insurance agents in Northeast Florida.