Mayday Handcrafted Ice Cream

Lovely ice cream place with a bunch of fun, new flavors and fun toppings! They offer complimentary sprinkles and a little waffle cone cookie if you want it. Staff were a bit overwhelmed the last time we visited but many of the other times have been great. The line may look long but it is worth it.

So many fun and delicious flavors, and Gisele was so kind letting us try as many of them as we wanted! 🍨 A bit pricey for the amount you get, but when you’re on a beach vacation what do you expect 🌊☀️😂 and the ice cream tasted very high quality to us! Super creamy with lots of great mix-ins 😊

Awesome! Ice cream, I got the North Polepermint and it was a perfect blend of peppermint that was not over powering, we also got Favorite Mug Espresso Chip and a vanilla with sprinkles. Total was about $16 not bad but there are gluten free options, non dairy, and sprinkles on the name cards mean seasonal. Great spot right by the beach, plenty of room; inside and out. Shout out to Kristin! She was great, friendly, and very open to allowing us to try every sample before making a selection. We'll be back!

We stopped by Mayday Ice Cream in St. Augustine for a sweet treat as a party of 6, and it was such a great experience! Gisele was an absolute doll—so kind, welcoming, and genuinely engaging with all of us. She made the visit even more special. The ice cream was out of this world! We loved being able to sample different flavors, but I went with the brown butter chocolate chip cookie—and WOW, it was AMAZING. Seriously one of the best scoops I’ve had. We’ll definitely be back and highly recommend stopping in if you’re in the area! 🍦 ⭐️ ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ 🍦