Bronx House Pizza - St. Johns

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ I absolutely LOVE Bronx House Pizza! From the first bite, you can tell they care about quality. The crust is perfectly cooked with just the right texture, the sauce is full of flavor without overpowering the pizza, and the presentation is just as impressive as the taste. Everything about this place feels authentic and made with pride. If you’re looking for pizza that hits all the right notes, Bronx House Pizza is definitely worth the visit. I’ll absolutely be back!

I never write reviews but this one has to be known! Do you like your pizza the way you order and pay for it? Well don’t come to Bronx pizza house in St.Johns. They make it however they feel like it the unfriendly rude young waitresses at the counter make you feel like they are doing you a favor when speaking to them. I asked for light cheese on my pizza order and they decided to put no cheese on it and when I asked them why is there no cheese the young waitress said “We don’t do any modifications here”. I never heard of a pizza shop that doesn’t do modifications if I knew that I would’ve gotten a frozen pizza… The waitress continued to argue with me about my order. I left with the my no cheese pizza and never plan to return back. Bronx get better professional wait staff and train your workers to be accommodating and understanding to the paying customers.

I recently tried a delivery from Bronx House Pizza at this location and was impressed with the quality. The crust hit that perfect sweet spot—crispy with a nice crunch but still tender enough to bite through easily, not overly hard or brittle. I ordered the buffalo chicken pizza and garlic knots, and both exceeded expectations. The buffalo chicken pizza had a solid balance of flavors with quality toppings, while the garlic knots were fresh and juicy. Everything tasted like it was made with care rather than just rushed out. For a local pizza spot, the food quality here is definitely above average.​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​ Will definitely order again