Scully's Irish Pub & Eatery

I had a few things I wanted to try, but when I saw shaved corned beef on their Reuben, I decided that’s what I wanted. When I gave my order to the server, I specified how I was excited to try it because it was shaved, and he told me it was his favorite, but he could never finish it. When the food came, I was very nervous because not only was the rye bread seeded, and I don’t like seeded rye bread typically, the meat was clearly not shaved, but sliced. Once I took a bite, all of those concerns were gone! Not only was it such fresh and delicious bread that I am certain they must make or get fresh from a bakery, the corned beef had to be the most tender I’ve had in a very long time. There was not one chewy piece throughout the sandwich. Now, those fries…they are now my absolute favorite fries! I can see myself craving those. I didn’t even get through half of the sandwich because it was a lot. My husband really enjoyed the smash burger as well. He said his bun was also very fresh and delicious, the burger was great, too! The pub itself it very cute and just was you would expect to see and a friendly atmosphere to go with it.

Is it rude to lick the plate?! 😂 This place has everything you'd want in an Irish Pub in Fernandina Beach, Florida, USA!!! The bartenders are friendly and courteous! Krissa made our gastronomical endeavor extremely fun and enjoyable! The Killkenny and Guinness pours were bang-on perfectly poured as they are supposed to be experienced! The Irish Smash Burger is a must try! It has salty, savory smash burger patties with a great tangy sauce to cut the heaviness of the burger/bun combination. The bangers and mash were simply and classically savory and soul-filling! Finally, for a warm Irish treat, Krissa made absolutely perfect Irish coffees which we could devour until bad things happen! 😂 We love the atmosphere, food, and most importantly...the drinks here!

The food was okay to good. The people I went with said the fried pickles were good as it had the right amount of breading. I had the burger and it was just okay. There were very light staffed. Christian was awesome though. Great attitude and attentive. It smelled inside the place which was a little unappealing. You may want to sit outside to have a more enjoyable experience. This is not on my preferred places to eat list.

We’ve been watching House of Guinness on Netflix and had it in our heads to get some at an Irish pub. After checking reviews on two in Fernandina I picked Scully’s. It’s a place we’ve walked past many times but never noticed it or knew it was there. Sort of down an alley and squeezed between two other places. But we made the right choice and will be back! The food was great! And the beers great…and poured correctly. Kiernan (I think that was our servers name) was awesome and fun to talk to. He knew a lot and really took care of us.