Renna's Pizza

I stopped here for dinner after a 12 hour drive and to be honest I was not impressed. The restaurant is located in a strip center so there's ample parking and the grounds were well maintained. I was informed upon arrival by the staff that they were doing carry-out only even though I arrived at 8:00 pm and the restaurant doesn't close till 9:00 pm. Not a deal breaker, but it would have been nice to sit at a table and dine after driving all day. The staff was clean, but offered no greeting upon entering and appeared to lack any enthusiasm (except the cook). While it isn't mandatory to greet your customers, not doing so does set a tone for the rest of the visit. The interior is pretty blasé and doesn't have any charm or individuality that stand out from any other facility. In short, it's generic, but it was clean which is most important. I ordered a thin crust cheese pizza and Caesar salad that came out pretty quick and out the door I went. The food made me regret my decision to dine here as the pizza had a strong dried oregano presence and the sauce was unnaturally sweet which makes me believe there is sugar in the pizza sauce. The cheese had little to no stretch and was definitely a mixture. The pizza is also more bar-style pizza vs. a traditional chewy NY style pizza, but the crust did have a decent underside and decent flavor. The Caesar salad was an abomination as it was pure Iceberg lettuce and not the advertised "greens" on the menu. The dressing was a jarred, mass produced creamy Caesar that didn't have good flavor as were the croutons. Value wise it's a little overpriced given the quality of the food, but the portions were sized right for the price point. I can't recommend this place based on my experience, but they do have many other items on the menu that they might excel at so others may enjoy this place whereas I did not.

01/08/2026: Went to pickup a pizza to go. Haven't been here since early 2000's but my son who's a senior is obsessed with this place. Told him I'll buy dinner here. Got the X-Large Renna's special or something like that. Thought it was pricey but when I got home, I underestimated the value. It's defined not overpriced and freaking good as hell. Stop eating Little Caesars guys and get a pizza here. Holy cow its good!

My family and I have been coming here for years and have a lot of memories here. Now is time to make some new ones with my toddler. The food is great (for the price), the wait time is reasonable, and the staff is always friendly and welcoming. The tables are clean, and the beers are reasonably priced, great pizza joints. Thank you, team Renna's! 🍕 🍕 🍕

Finally a place with slices!!!! And so God! Decebt price. The lady Kim behind the counter was attentive, polite and super quick!!! Such a relief to eat somewhere new and have such a great experience. Coming back!