Millie's Homemade Ice Cream

If you are looking to eat oil, gums, dyes, carrageenan (research it no seriously) then this is NOT the place for you. They have real ice cream here just like when you were a kid (if you are over 30). Found ourselves here after looking up Brusters real homemade ice cream (which isn’t real homemade it is full of chemicals) I called up Millie’s and they said yes they are all real homemade. We went by and grabbed some. Sophie was very sweet and helpful. The ice cream flavors are all great went with the classic chocolate, and then also a vanilla coconut dairy free. they both were really good. Highly recommend.

Probably some of the yummiest ice cream I’ve ever eaten! Maybe because are grass fed and genuinely happy. We enjoyed butter pecan and cookies and cream in a waffle cone. Plentiful in the pecans and generous with the cookies! We detected cinnamon in the waffle cone, we decided the cone smelled and tasted a bit like a snicker doodle. Millie’s is relatively small and parking is not easy as it located downtown San Marco but that the joy of ice cream…walking around, talking and enjoying the moments. The staff were very friendly. Enjoy pints, cold brews, floats, sundaes, shakes and gelato. Vegan, gluten and dairy free options.

Great Ice Cream Selection, But Room for Improvement The ice cream was tasty with plenty of flavors — a nice mix of classic favorites and creative options. However, the customer service felt a bit lacking, and the cleanliness could definitely be better. Worth a visit for the variety, but the overall experience could use a little polish.

Been in here twice now, and both times were great. Employees were kind and quick to take orders. I’ve had the cookie dough each time, and it’s delicious. I always get a laugh when I see the Lactaid on the counter since I am lactose intolerant, but I still indulge here!