Mayday Handcrafted Ice Cream San Marco

I had a fantastic experience here! The staff members are incredibly friendly, patient, and helpful. The shop itself is spotless, and the location is stunning, offering plenty of parking and both indoor/outdoor seating options. As for the ice cream, it was delicious! I tried a few different flavors: Brown Butter Chocolate Chip: Absolutely perfect. Bourbon Pecan: A must-try (just a heads-up, it contains a small amount of alcohol, so you might need your ID!). Midnight Chocolate: Truly excellent for fellow chocolate lovers. Banana Pudding: Very good, though I was expecting a slightly stronger banana flavor. While the topping selection is a bit limited, the hot fudge is a must-try! Everything was so good that I finished it all before I could take a photo."

I was on a business trip and we stopped into this ice cream after dinner on our walk back to hotel and I'm so glad we did!! Ice cream was like homemade deliciousness. Great flavors. The gentlemen working was so nice and friendly. Inside was clean. Definitely recommend!

We had an hour to waste between check out at the hotel and need to get to airport. This was an 11 minute walk from our hotel. I really like ice cream and go to a lot of ice cream spots. So I don’t mean it lightly when I say this is one of the best spots I’ve been to in a while. I really liked the different flavor choices. I couldn’t make up my mind and ended up with a flight. The Oreo and peanut but ice cream was my favorite, but aviator was excellent too. The cookies and cream was like eating an ice cream Oreo. They have some no dairy options. There were some fruity options that I would like to try next time. The guy working there the fall flavors would be out soon, so it seems the menu changes. He was really nice and friendly. The cookies are massive and looked delicious, but we didn’t have stomach space for it. We were sorry we didn’t find this place earlier in our stay. We didn’t think to take pictures as we were so busy enjoying it.