DeCicco's Pizzeria

went here for the first time last night and it was so good!! we ordered two whole pizzas, and a slice of pizza, and all were so good!! have been looking for a good NY style thin crust and this place is definitely it! all the employees were so nice and fun too! they gave us some zeppoles to try as well and they were so good! will definitely be back!

All around AMAZING! The slices were fresh, warmed to order and so delicious!!! I had hot honey pepperoni, Hawaiian, deluxe, and they were all so good! also had the opportunity to try some of their pinwheels quickly realized I’ve been missing out—they were full of meat cheese, and fresh vegetables, perfectly crispy on the outside and gooey and melty on inside. Wings, fried to order with the perfect crunch too. The staff are all very friendly, a real family vibe—shoutout to Chris and Rosario with her beautiful smiling face!! I cannot say enough about this place. I’m visiting from Virginia and will definitely come in every time I come to town. I will also be telling all my Jacksonville/Yulee family to take their business to DeCicco’s—hands down the best!!

I had to double check my map to make sure I was actually in Yulee, FL! DeCicco’s was recommended to me by a fellow “Yankee” who told me it’s the best pizza around. Having high hopes, I stopped in for a pizza and drove 30+ minutes home with it to Brunswick. He wasn’t kidding! My aunt, who was visiting from NJ at the time, raved about the pizza and we all agreed it tasted like “home”. After dreaming about the food for a couple months, I stopped in again tonight with a friend on my way back from a shopping trip in Jacksonville. She had a slice of Sicilian pizza and baked ziti. I opted for the chicken parm with vodka sauce. Absolutely delicious and everything was super fresh. Before we left, the owner sent over an order of Zeppoles. I haven’t had a zeppole since I was a kid and it brought back so much nostalgia. Such a tasty treat and a very kind gesture. I really enjoyed speaking with him and look forward to continuing to support his business. I ordered a slice of rainbow cake to go because it reminded me of my Grandma’s rainbow cookies. I haven’t tried that yet, but I’m sure it will be delicious! Thank you DeCicco’s for making me feel right at home!

If you're hunting for a truly authentic New York-style slice in the area, DeCicco's is a great choice. The crust hits all the right notes with that classic, foldable texture, and the pizza overall is consistently well-made. The staff is incredibly friendly and welcoming, which makes for an easy, casual dining experience. They really go out of their way to make you feel welcome. They even gave our boys free ice pops! Delicious food, excellent service, and a nice local spot to grab a bite. We'll definitely be back!